The Problem with Pakistan - Instablogs
The Problem with Pakistan
Dayasurabhi Balaji , Pune: Aug 12 2008
Made Popular Aug 14 2008
Pakistan :

The Problem with Pakistan

Ever since it’s Independence Pakistan seems to be grappling under pressure of various issues, beginning with history and religion, which still needs solutions. And so unfortunate is the factor that the country’s politics is enmeshed with these two haunting elements and have almost become inseparable. This is one reason why Pakistani politics is unstable with literally no organized and stable political idea or constitution.

To glance its pages of history since East Bengal Movement (1971) which eventually led to the creation of Bangladesh, one would know where precisely their problem begins. In 1948, Jinnah declared that Urdu be the only language of Pakistan; interestingly there begins the schism; later on developing into favoritism between the East and West Pakistan, leading the country to devastating civil war. This apart, another factor contributing strife in the internal affairs of government was Ahmadiya Movement: according to the Pakistani government Ahmadis are non-Muslims-this led to lot of internal religious struggle, the strains visible even today- so Pakistan is reeling under sectarianism from the initial period. After Yahya Khan and Bhutto, Zia- ul- Haq introduced Islamic Law – Sharia, the repercussions of it took away freedom from the ordinary citizens who came under attack and criticism of religious parties- from then on politics never really represented common people. It was just a bargain with people as pawns.

What is interesting to note in such a scenario is Pakistan’s foreign relations. Pakistan has been an ally of United States of America since the Cold War Era and its relationship with China, Russia and Afghanistan and even India has been very active. But Pakistan failed to give attention to its own people or domestic politics. The active role it played during Soviet invasion of Afghanistan proved its own demise with subsequent Talibanisation and US invasion of Afghanistan. The already crippling economy and wartime activities never gave people of Pakistan time to peep into its own political history with army and civilian coup every decade and when it did it seemed always too late and almost after every coup the country falls into same kind of system- anarchy.

Another aspect Pakistan refuses to accept is the cultural bind that it shares with rest of Asia. Pakistan is deliberately and forcefully alienating itself from the root of its tradition. Islam if seen as per history goes back to Middle East origin and it can be said without doubt that the emergence of Urdu dates back roughly from the period of Akbar- especially in and around the vicinities of Delhi. It cannot deny the cultural, geographical and historical bind it shares with India. And once Pakistan learns to look to India as a friendly neighbor, most of the issues may find early resolve, but rather it looks to India as its worst enemy.

Pakistan must learn from its past. But it does not. The energy it directs towards fighting insurgency, mostly because of its foreign assignments and religious intolerance within the country, within the sects, should be put an end, making a way towards peaceful and stable democratic constitution. Pakistan should get enough time to ponder what its politics has come up to and seriously think of a solution that can long last. People should know where the religion ends and politics begin, and they must also essentially understand that for its society to survive it has to put back religious fervor as social phenomena to personal factor. The society of Pakistan is as diverse as it is in India – the only difference being moderates and orthodox, I mean the various Islamic sects within. It cannot choose to wipe out moderates, who exist elsewhere or in their own country, for history goes deep down. They must aim for religious tolerance, other things follow afterwards. Once religion becomes a personal affair, political transformation is inevitable- then political system would become stable and concentrate on development.

Hope the country does not face another impeachment.

Image:Foxnews

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
DonaldJ
Winnipeg, MB, Canada
Any bets that Pakistan is the core HQ’s of all the terrorist groups of the world, all but United States... Me think Pakistan has been lying to our faces forever, even before we gave them nuclear technologies... I sees a war started after a nuke sails from Pakistan to Israel.. then a couple nukes from Israel to Pakistan.. then all hell breaks loose.. then the tons of radioactive dust falls all over the planet in the next two years, extincting the planet’s pollinators.. then we and everything progressively runs out of food... We’re Screwed!..
1 Stars
Hassan Rizvi
Lahore, Pakistan
Hi Donald J,

Thank you so much for giving us nuclear technologies.....but the way I remember it the USA and the rest of the world wore their trousers off trying to deny it to us;including stopping of all aid and sanctions!

Let me give you some more surprises here.For a country which on independence couldn’t even make paper pins we today make our own fourth generation fighter Jets,one of the world’s best tanks;all types of canons and mortars; not to mention alltypes of missiles including a 500 km range nuclear tipped cruise missile.

We are working on ICBM’s And SLV’s -you’ll get the good news of their arrival soon.

And Yes -should Israel or anyone else for that matter try anything funny-they should remember no country makes these weapons just for display.

Here’s hoping people like you don’t end up screwing the concept of nuclear detterance!
1 Stars
Fariha Jamil
Lahore, Pakistan
Dear Dayasurabhi Balaji,

Its always nice to point the wrong with other others countries and never good to listen to any true problems that exist within your own country.

I can also come up with an article telling ple much about the ever persistent issues in India.... Different communities with different identities - regional, language, caste, religion - demanded different rights for their communities. Some communities demanded more autonomy for their cultures within the Indian states. Others demanded autonomous states within the Indian Union, while the others demanded to be independent from India....

But i feel instead of highlighting others issues we should tell good things about each other ’if’ we want peace in our world. You can tell bad things abt us, we can tell u bad things abt u, USA can tell bad things abt us and vise versa... this will take us nowhere. This pleasure of throwing crap at eachother will only multiply hatred.

Let us for once percieve all as humans like ourselves and all nations as respectable with watever issues they have, be it pakistan , india, usa or canada...

May be you would like to read this :)

http://fariha.instablogs.com/entry/jai-hind-and-pakistan-zindabad/

God bless all!
1 Stars
Hi!

It was an outsider perspective of Pakistan and politics - something completely about political issues in the country - nothing personal at all, nor anything with the people. The country Pakistan as such is rich both in heritage and culture which it shares with millions of people - but politics in Pakistan needs transformation.

When I refer to Pakistan - it means Pakistan government and political players.

Indeed! God bless us all.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Fariha Jamil
Lahore, Pakistan
Thanks for re assuring dear! Pakistanis are fed up of this political crap and then the international world pointing that is painful because the politicians remain as untouched and rigid, and the feelings of poor civilians get hurt :(
1 Stars
Hassan Rizvi
Lahore, Pakistan
Dayasurabhi Balaji,

There is no doubt that relations between India and Pakistan will worsen because of what is happening in Kashmir right now.

And many people like you will contribute towards further poisoning of the atmosphere.

Before chosing to show such ’heartfelt sympathy’ for Pakistani politics wouldn’t it have been better if you had tried to write something to correct the politico-religious problems India is facing.I already mentioned one;their is of course the growing Hindu-Muslim terrorism - not because of ISI mind you-but because of growing Hindu militancy;and what about the Dalit issue I could post some remarkably gripping pictures too.... Ofcourse the people of India are so good,it is the government I am talking off.What double talk is this that I am making!

Better still couldn’t you have written something to improve the situation ,rather then making a negative contribution.

What was the purpose of your blog,I didn’t see a single constructive suggestion in it?
1 Stars
There are informed writers from Pakistan who can throw better light on the problems than us outsiders.

Pakistan is a rogue state.

Pakistan is a dream come true holy state for indian muslims of pre-independence era. Pak is an acronym of Punjab, Afghanistan and Kashmir; the muslim dominated areas of pre-partition days. Later events have proved that Pakistan keeps an evil eye on Kashmir. Kasmiris raise the bogey of Azadi from time to time. Similarly China claims Arunachal Pradesh as part of Mangolian culture and facial appearance.

All muslims are not terrorists. India had patriotic presidents in Dr. Zakir Hussain, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmad and Dr. Abdul Kalam. Our cricket team was captained by Nawab M.A.K. Pataudi and Md. Azharuddin. Our bollywood stars namely Aamir, Salman and Shahrukh are the dream of young Hindu girls of India. Dialogue of television serial Mahabharat was written by a Muslim. Mohd Karim Chagla and Md. Hidaytulla were our Chief Justices of Supreme Court. I can name hundreds distinguished muslims who are good and patriotic Indians.

Terrorism in India started with Naxalite movement. Naxalites are Hindus. Militancy took ugly turn with Sikh majority when Punjab was boiling. They are not muslims. Nagaland, Assam, NEFA, Tripura are on boil since independence. These are not muslim majority states. Bangladesh is not a terrorist country although a majority of Bangladeshis are muslims.

Urdu is a very rich, lovable and sophisticated language. It does not create strife.
1 Stars
Hassan Rizvi
Lahore, Pakistan
Pakistan is a dream come true for the people of the Indus Valley Civilisation,who happen to be Muslims now.We are the people of The Indus.

We existed as a people even before Chandra Gupta or Asoka ruled ,or any Ghori or Ghaznanavi or Qasim came here.And we exist as a people now.We are the best of friends to our friends;but terrorists for our enemies......And we will ever remain so.

It is the oldest civilistion known to man.Some people are so proud of our heritage,that they claim it as theirs.

Genetic sciences prove that the original people anywhere in the sub-continent are present pre-dominantly only in regions of Pakistan ;all the people of India are predominantely a mix of six outside races.

Pakistan never marched into states like Kashmir,Junagarh,Manvadar,Sikkim etc etc

Pakistan does not have twenty two families that owns 80% of the wealth of the nation,while 60% of it starves.

Pakistan does not have half the problems you have educationally ,socially,politically ,religiously etc.

India’s battle Tank and jet fighter never took off and had to be scrapped after misappropriation of billions of Indian Ruppees.Remember India was so advanced in 1947 that it had made it’s first airplane twenty years earlier.But your people are so corrupt and inefficient that today Pakistan which at Independence could not make a paper pin is making one of the best tanks in the world Al-Khalid.Is making a better jet fighter then you;while both yours? Scrapped!!!!We are a nuclear power and have a more advanced missile program then you.Know why?

Because we are all equal-in the mosque ;while eating;while asking for our rights; while questioning our rulers.-even if they be dictators .And you.Look at your problems and cry:Dalits ,50% of the population treated as slaves-killed and murdered at whims while people grab their lands.The Sikhs,the Mizos,the Tamils,the Muslims,the Kashmiris,the Christians,....I could go on and on butchered at one time or the others at your blood stained hands.And we are the terrorists.....Think again misguided patroit.
1 Stars
your pride and prejudices, envy and ingnorance are understandable.

Your facts are wrong as far as Kasmir issue is concerned. From where did you get the figure that 60% Indians starve?

Every one is equal before God whether he is in a mosque, praying in a temple or in a church or in any other religious place of worship. God does not bestow special favours to you if you sit on a bench in a church and pray or sit on a throne and pray. God has not made people equal. The religious rituals to make them appear equal is cosmetic.

If you point out certain problems which you feel are no problems elsewhere; that just does not wash away the stigma of a terrorist state from the head of Pakistan.Of course, you are free to hold your own misinformed opinion about us.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Hassan Rizvi
Lahore, Pakistan
Hi All,
The above is posted most regretfully as the most civilised reply I could give to minds on both sides of the border which still carry -and wish to perpetuate - the hatreds and follies of the past.Hope you will understand.
1 Stars
You are welcome to give your honest, unbiased, analytical, informed views on any subject under the sun. A civilised person speaks a civilised language even in disagreements. I assume, you are a civilised person. Even if you are not, I value your opinion.

I have not given you the liberty to question my patriotism or put motive of hatred on my freedom of expression.
(Global Perspectives)
Add your Comment